CareerConnector vs Handshake. Was the switch worth it?

No matter what it concerns, change always faces backlash. There is comfort in things staying how they have always been. That said, change can be a great thing. This year, Willamette switched from the career networking site Handshake to a new site, CareerConnector. Though transitions can be trying, switching to CareerConnector was best for Willamette’s students because CareerConnector offers a smoother way to find both on- and off-campus resources.
The biggest drawback to Handshake was its website was hard to understand and not very intuitive. A platform with a steep learning curve is not ideal for a place where students go to find resources and connections. Cassie Thomas (’27), who previously used Handshake for finding on-campus jobs, commented, “It was just not common sense.”
Lisa Truong (’27), who also used Handshake for finding on-campus jobs, remarked, “I think that for connecting with career advisors it was slightly difficult; I didn't really understand the formatting of it.”
Handshake provided its users with an awkward, finicky experience. Rylie Hooley (’27), who used the website to search for on-campus jobs, off-campus jobs and internships, said, “As the platform kept growing and expanding, they started adding different features into it that weren't necessarily helpful for people who were either looking for jobs or looking to network. It was kind of a very clunky thing.”
In contrast, CareerConnector offers a clear menu bar with tabs separating on-campus jobs, off-campus jobs, resources, advising information and more.
Handshake was ready to be retired. Its system is needlessly complicated, with features that cause more confusion than clarification. One of these features is its AI tools. Handshake comes with multiple AI features whose uses are not entirely clear. It reads like just another website jumping on the AI bandwagon with no real benefit to users.
Another unnecessary and annoying feature is its “feed” tab, where users can view and interact with posts from employers and other users. Obviously, this is modeled after a social media feed in an odd attempt to appeal to its majority college student users. It doesn’t promote a sense of professionalism and is an altogether pointless feature.
In contrast to Handshake’s unorganized structure, CareerConnector is a breath of fresh air. Before even logging in to the website, a photo of Willamette’s iconic Mill Stream fills the screen. It is immediately clear that it is a tool to connect with the community both on campus and off.
CareerConnector is more Willamette-specific than Handshake. Resources Willamette offers to its students are more easily available than on the former platform.
“There was a disconnect of where I feel like Handshake was ‘this is just a platform that's used by the university,’ where I feel like CareerConnector has a lot more of those Willamette resources that are helpful for students,” Hooley said.
Another great thing about CareerConnector is its access to resources, both through Willamette and outside it. Events are posted on CareerConnector that are both Willamette-specific and from the outside community, and one can register for them directly on the CareerConnector website. It offers a clear distinction between on- and off-campus jobs with separate tabs for both. CareerConnector also has an easily accessible resource library. The resource library is easy to find and contains many helpful documents, such as career planning and graduate school information.
Although switching any platform can be difficult at first, it can be better in the long run. Thomas summed up, “It was just that [Handshake] was widely used… but CareerConnector, I feel, is so much better for students.”
In a time when it may feel like so many things are changing at Willamette, it is easy to assume that all of those changes will be bad. However, the switch to CareerConnector makes Willamette students’ search for jobs smoother.




Comments