Opinion: Democrats need to embrace socialism

On election night, Democrats exceeded expectations, surprising pollsters, journalists and politicians alike. At the time of writing, Democrats won a majority in both the House of Representatives and the Senate, with 54 of 100 seats in the Senate and 254 of 435 seats in the House. Across Congress, there are races yet to be called, but Democrats will have a majority in both chambers regardless of the outcomes of said races. Most political pundits agree that dissatisfaction with Trump and the high cost of living won Democrats the midterms.
Despite the blue wave, it’s not all smooth sailing for Democrats. Addressing the affordability crisis is far more complicated and challenging than pointing it out.
Throughout the midterm campaign season, President Donald Trump reiterated the same message: ‘vote like I’m on the ballot.’ Bold, coming from a president with a historically low approval rating. But Trump has always been bold. From the day he announced his candidacy in June of 2015, he disregarded conventional wisdom and political norms. It’s served him well so far, so why should he expect anything different now?
Unfortunately for Trump and the GOP, not even Trump’s cult of personality or his loyal base could protect him from the outrage of the American people. Trump ran on a populist platform. He promised to prioritize Americans, bring down prices and cease American involvement in foreign wars. Yet nearly every decision Trump has made since taking office has increased the cost of living for everyday Americans.
Trump’s complete disregard for the economic plight of the average American helped Democrats secure victory, but his failure also serves as a warning for what could befall Democrats if they’re not careful.
Despite historic wins for Democrats, most voters aren’t pleased with the Democratic Party; they’re just angrier at Republicans. According to a survey by Pew Research Center, 58% of U.S. adults have an unfavorable view of the Republican Party. A nearly identical share — 59% — have an unfavorable view of the Democratic Party. The political establishment is seen as out of touch, ineffective and more concerned with their future electability than serving their constituents in the present.
The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC) and National Republican Congressional Committee (NRCC) have spent more money campaigning in the past couple of months than most Americans will see in their lifetimes. While this spending may have helped secure Democratic seats, it still serves to distance politicians from the communities they represent.
The Democratic establishment is particularly alienating for young progressives. These divides haven’t gone away just because Democrats have been able to converge on affordability. For example, polling shows that gas prices are Americans' top concern with the war in Iran. Many people are mad about how the challenges of shipping oil through the Strait of Hormuz impact gas prices, but conversations about the impact on Iranian people and the war as a continuation of American imperialist policy are barely present in mainstream political discourse.
These distinctions do not prevent consensus and collective action. Coalitions are inherently composed of distinct entities, bound together by a shared common goal. Just as ideological variety does not guarantee doom, ideological purity does not guarantee success. Seeking perfection can often be counterproductive and lead organizations to devolve into infighting. The temporality of coalitions does not devalue them.
However, the temporary nature of these alliances must not be ignored. To return to the prior example, the war in Iran, if people’s only issue with the war in Iran is that it makes gas more expensive for Americans, when American imperialism is profitable again, the coalition will fall apart. This may prevent the Democratic Party from addressing the root causes of the affordability crisis.
On Nov. 8, House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries gave an interview with ABC, where he affirmed Democrats’ commitment to making America more affordable. When asked for specifics on his approach, Jeffries said Democrats need to stop Trump’s tariffs, reverse Medicaid cuts, SNAP cuts and to extend the Affordable Care Act tax credits. These actions will likely have positive short-term impacts, but they only reverse the impacts of Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill, while doing nothing to address the cost of living crisis that made Trump popular in the first place. They don’t address wages being outpaced by inflation, increasing income inequality, or the ever-consolidating economic and political power in the U.S. These policy suggestions are a mere band-aid over a gaping wound.
This critique doesn’t mean Jeffries needs to pick up the Communist Manifesto and embrace the socialist label. That’s an unrealistic goal. The ghost of McCarthyism and the Red Scare still haunts American politics. Texas Senator-elect James Talarico’s victory speech echoed Marxist rhetoric, yet he explicitly distances himself from the socialist label, proving that despite politicians' willingness to embrace economic populism, the labels still send a shiver down their spines.
However, if the Democratic establishment avoids socialist policies altogether, they will only provide a brief respite from economic instability before income inequality and the affordability crisis worsen. Even when the midterm ‘anti-Trump pro-affordability’ coalition inevitably devolves, the Democratic Party needs to figure out how socialists and establishment Dems can coexist, or risk years of losses and a miserable future for the American people.
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article represent the opinions of Maisy Clunies-Ross. This is separate from her role at The Collegian and these views are not necessarily representative of the perspective of The Collegian as a whole.




Comments